Feedback Form

Meet the Old Palin, Not the Same as the New Palin

By Peter Suderman

Looking at the old Palin debate clip Conor linked to, I think it’s clear that the folksiness she displayed in the recent debate is a recent addition to her public persona. And I think it’s reasonable to infer that, as with most every development in a major campaign like these, these tics were added intentionally, layered on like an actor building a character — and, most importantly, that they are products of campaign-trail training.

What that says, to me at least, is that Palin was pushed into this. Maybe she went along willingly, but I just can’t believe that this dramatic shift in her persona was primarily her idea. She’s been surrounded by McCain advisers since accepting the VP nomination — the same advisers who’ve been running a sleazy, stupid, below-the-belt campaign focused entirely on issues of perception and personality. Running Palin entirely on her faux outsider cred, playing up the folksy rhetoric, ignoring substantive policy and heaping abuse on the coastal media rather than focusing on issues — all of this smacks of the sort of slimy tactics the McCain campaign has specialized in over the last few months. Palin, I suspect, was simply told by McCain’s people that this was how she’d run her campaign, and she, as someone with little experience or clout on the national stage, went along. Perhaps she bears some culpability for going along with the charade, but I’m increasingly convinced that Palin’s failures are, by and large, failures of McCain and his campaign staff.

UPDATE: Fixed a few grammatical errors. Never post in haste, kids.

3 Responses to “Meet the Old Palin, Not the Same as the New Palin”

  1. 1
    Jason Says:

    Why doesn’t McCain’s campaign trust real conservative ideas? Why are they tied up in utterly transparent identity politics?

  2. 2
    Faking It (II) « Upturned Earth || John Schwenkler Says:

    […] October 6, 2008, 11:01 am Filed under: media/culture, politics So Conor Friedersdorf and Peter Suderman have both jumped on board the “fake folksiness” wagon, and as I said on Friday, I just […]

  3. 3
    The Confabulum » Blog Archive » Or Maybe She is Folksy Says:

    […] Schwenkler says that Peter and I are wrong to claim that Sarah Palin’s folksy manner in the last debate is affected. […]

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image

Most Recent
The Manners In Which We Live
Life after the marriage war.
The World Obama Faces: Take Cover
How soft is Obama's soft power?
Working Girl
30 Rock: The cruelest satire of single women on TV.
Location Matters!
Give the people federalism (except for racists!)
The World Obama Faces: Muddle East
Iran and Afghanistan and Pakistan! Oh my!
Recent Diaries
The Evangelical Party At Prayer
I was emailing today with a few right-of-center eminenc ...
Marriage and Definitions (re: Mollie Hemingway)
Mollie Hemingway recently asked commenters to post resp ...
Pimp Story, Or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Death Threat
[Note: circa 2007, I worked for a little over a year at ...
A Libertarian Case Against Legal Prostitution
With all of the other excitement surrounding the electi ...